epl streaming

Saturday, December 5, 2009

Play Offs - The Fairest Way

With end-of-season play-offs in full swing in football and rugby union, the excitement generated is usually accompanied by complaints about the unfairness of it all.

Unsurprisingly, the wronged side is always the one that finished its league campaign higher.

Let's start with the Guinness Premiership. After a gruelling 22 rounds lasting eight months, why shouldn't Leicester Tigers be called this year's champions rather than having to compete in an end of season mini-cup competition? Will third-placed London Irish take that honour?

To answer that we can take a look at Rugby Union's once disowned family member, Rugby League. Play-offs have been prevalent in Rugby League since the Northern Union first split away at the end of the 19th century, when Hunslet and Bradford Northern tied for points at the top of the Yorkshire Competition. It was also used extensively when the two divisions were merged into one and an odd fixture list developed that prevented everyone playing each other twice.

That system ended in 1973 but Rugby League then invented an end-of-season competition, "The Premiership" to generate some more interest. At this point the League Championship was seen as far more important and the new play-off style idea didn't carry much gravitas until the Super League itself was formed in 1998.

Despite the same resistance as is now seen in Rugby Union, it's now accepted in Rugby League circles that the Super League Grand Final winners are the champions regardless of where they finished during the regular season. A lot of this can be put down to the play-off system itself, but more of that later.

Football League teams are also competing for promotion with the Championship (Division 2 in old money) play-off final routinely called the richest prize in football due to its opening up of Premier League bounty for the Wembley winners.

Despite the excitement produced by play-offs there's still a considerable body of opinion opposed to them despite their continued existence since 1987.

To me, the problem is caused by the way they are organised, and this is where the other sports might like to copy the Super League format, itself a copy of the Australian version known as the McIntyre system after its inventor Ken McIntyre.

There are now McIntyre systems for four teams through to eight, but let's see how the four team version differs from the simplistic models used by the Football League and Rugby Union.

In the 1st round the highest two ranked teams play each other with the winner going straight through to the Grand Final, but the loser goes into the next round.

The lowest two ranked teams play each other with the loser being eliminated and the winner going into the next round.

The winner of the second round match goes into the Grand Final.

In this way, the top two ranked sides can each afford to lose a game yet can still make the final. Under this system, a side winning the play-off must beat all the teams that finished above it during the regular season.

This is a much fairer way of doing business and I am surprised it hasn't already been adopted as the standard by other sports.

Whether your team gets itself into the play-off lottery, it can get its football kit, rugby kit or basketball kit from Blue Moon Sport www.bluemoonsport.co.uk.